DeVos Faces Withering Criticism 03/21 06:14
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Education Secretary Betsy DeVos faced tough questions
from House Democrats on Tuesday on gun control, racial bias and civil rights as
she sought to defend funding cuts for her agency.
DeVos' testimony in front of the House Appropriations subcommittee got so
tense at certain moments that the chairman made a point of thanking DeVos for
her poise when he concluded the meeting.
DeVos, already reeling after a series of rocky, high-profile interviews,
unveiled some details of a federal commission on school safety that she will be
chairing. The commission, formed after the Florida high school shooting in
which 17 people were killed, will comprise herself as well as the heads of the
Homeland Security, Health and Human Services and Justice departments.
DeVos said the commission will begin work within the next few weeks. A
spokeswoman for DeVos later added that the panel will also involve students,
teachers, law enforcement and mental health professionals as experts.
DeVos said the commission will, among other things, consider whether to ban
gun sales to people under 21. President Donald Trump initially spoke in favor
of such a proposal, but backtracked on it after meeting with representatives of
the National Rifle Association. DeVos would not tell the subcommittee whether
she personally supports the idea or not.
DeVos also defended states' and communities' rights to decide whether to arm
"The question of school personnel being armed is very much one for local
communities and states to grapple with," she said.
DeVos added, "If there are going to be guns in schools, they need to be in
the hands of the right people, those who are going to protect students and
ensure their safety."
Rep. Andy Harris, R-Md., applauded DeVos for trying to upend the education
establishment and push for alternatives to neighborhood public schools. He
lamented that American students were scoring lower than many of their foreign
peers on international assessments.
"My gosh, the federal intrusion in education just hasn't worked and it's
time to drain the education swamp," Harris said.
Patty Murray of Washington state, the top Democrat on the Senate committee
overseeing education, was skeptical about the school safety commission. "I am
not very optimistic that that will accomplish anything," she told The
DeVos also faced sharp criticism from Rep. Barbara Lee, D-Calif., who
complained that minority students were being disciplined much more frequently
than their white peers for similar infractions. The Obama administration issued
guidance in 2014 that instructed schools to pay attention to the problem and
make sure they weren't discriminating against minority students.
"Your head is in the sand about racial bias and racial discrimination," Lee
said. "Madame Secretary, you just don't care much about the rights of black and
brown children. This is horrible."
DeVos is now reviewing that guidance, and civils rights group fear she
intends to rescind it. She would not talk about her plans at the hearing.
But DeVos said she was proud of the work of her agency's civil rights office
and said it was working to protect all students.
"There is no place for discrimination and there is no tolerance for
discrimination and we will continue to uphold that," she said.
Harris came to DeVos' defense, saying the Washington Opportunity
Scholarship, the nation's only federally-funded private school voucher program,
was helping raise graduation rates for minority students. He added that he has
received letters from one of his constituents who is complaining that schools
have become unsafe because teachers are afraid to discipline students out of
fear of sanctions from the federal government.
"I've been called racist. I guess that's the favorite thing to do to anyone
you disagree with and it's shameful, to be honest with you," Harris said.
Rep. Katherine Clark, D-Mass., launched into a tense back-and-forth with
DeVos on whether she would require private schools that receive federal funding
to follow federal civil rights laws that prohibit sexual, racial and religious
DeVos has been pushing to increase public funding of alternatives to
traditional neighborhood schools --- such as charter school or private school
programs. Critics say private schools get to choose which students to admit and
may discriminate against minorities.
"Will you guarantee as secretary of education that that money is included
with non-discrimination policies for those private schools?" Clark asked.
"Federal law must be followed when federal money is involved," DeVos said.
"Is that a yes or a no?"
DeVos kept repeating her answer.
"Is there some problem? Yes or no?"
"Yes," DeVos finally said.